| Platinum | Gyros on the Lake |
| Gold | Sultan's Mediterranean Grill |
| Silver | George's Greek Village |
| Bronze | Cafe Amore |
| Bronze | Joe Feta's Greek Village |
| Top Pick | Casa Toscana |
| Top Pick | Greek on Portage |
| Top Pick | It's About Thyme |
| Top Pick | Kasbah Mediterranean Qsine |
| Top Pick | Osmow's St. Catharines Scott St |
