| Platinum | Handlebar Hanks Roadhouse |
| Gold | Pie Guys Pizzeria |
| Gold | Tailgates Bar & Grill |
| Silver | Carson's Pizzeria Niagara Falls |
| Bronze | Cat's Caboose |
| Bronze | Trailsides |
| Top Pick | Casa D'Pizza |
| Top Pick | Hooligans Sports Bar |
| Top Pick | Lazy Lizard |
| Top Pick | Masi Central Pizzeria |
| Carmine's Pizzeria Italiano |
