| Platinum | Clancy's Too - Restaurant & Bar |
| Gold | Carmine's Pizzeria Italiano |
| Silver | South Coast Cookhouse |
| Bronze | Handlebar Hanks Roadhouse |
| Top Pick | Carson's Pizzeria Niagara Falls |
| Top Pick | Chip and Charlie's |
| Top Pick | Peter Piper's Pubhouse |
| Top Pick | Pie Guys Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Tailgates Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | The Trap Tap and Eatery |
