| Platinum | Cat's Caboose |
| Gold | Canalside |
| Silver | Ye Olde Squire Welland |
| Bronze | South Coast Cookhouse |
| Top Pick | Belmont Hotel Port Colborne |
| Top Pick | Bugsy's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Doc Magilligan's Restaurant & Irish Pub |
| Top Pick | Pie Guys Tap & Grill |
| Top Pick | The Feathery Pub |
| Top Pick | The Merchant Ale House |