| Platinum | Grumpy Gramma's |
| Gold | Bambi's Bistro |
| Silver | Carmine's Pizzeria Italiano |
| Silver | Gyros on the Lake |
| Bronze | Bacon Crazy |
| Bronze | Dohboy's Diner |
| Top Pick | Archie's Subs and Eatery |
| Top Pick | Carson's Pizzeria Niagara Falls |
| Top Pick | Storm's Fresh Meat & Deli |
| Top Pick | Submission Subs |