| Platinum | Mcuire |
| Gold | Copacabana Brazilian Steakhouse - Niagara |
| Silver | Matty Matheson's Meat and Three |
| Bronze | Angel's Diner |
| Top Pick | 1954 Bourbon & Smoke |
| Top Pick | Backroad Barbecue Company |
| Top Pick | Sassafras Coastal Kitchen & Bar |
| Top Pick | The Rib Crib & Smokeshop |