| Platinum | Value Village |
| Gold | Christian Benefit Shop |
| Silver | Goodwill Industries International |
| Bronze | Plato's Closet St. Catharines |
| Top Pick | Evergreen Thrift Store |
| Top Pick | Missions Thrift Store |
| Top Pick | New To You Thrift Shop |
| Top Pick | Port Colborne Thrift Store |
| Top Pick | Renewed Thrift & Vintage |
| Top Pick | St Vincent De Paul Society |