| Platinum | Gyros on the Lake |
| Gold | The Twisted Pig | Italian Kitchen |
| Silver | Cafe Amore |
| Bronze | Paris Crêpes Café |
| Top Pick | Blue Star Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Casa Toscana |
| Top Pick | Just Cooking Rustic Italian |
| Top Pick | Napoli Ristorante Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Polonia Meat & Deli |
| Top Pick | Your Deli Polonez |