| Platinum | San Marco's Ristorante, Port Colborne |
| Gold | Lina Linguini's Pasta & Grille |
| Silver | Zappi's Pizza & Pasta |
| Bronze | Coppola's Ristaurante |
| Top Pick | Casa Toscana |
| Top Pick | Four Brothers Cucina |
| Top Pick | Fresco's Restaurant & Bar |
| Top Pick | Napoli Ristorante Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Sweet Treats and Luncheon Meets |
| Top Pick | The Twisted Pig | Italian Kitchen |