| Platinum | Baby & Toddler Preloved |
| Gold | Twice as Nice Poco |
| Silver | Wild Daisies Consignment Clithing |
| Bronze | Renewed Thrift & Vintage |
| Top Pick | Goodwill Plymouth Rd Welland |
| Top Pick | New To You Thrift Shop |
| Top Pick | Sephlees Artisan Disciplines and Such |
| Top Pick | Vintage Venture |