| Platinum | The Frugal Dutchman |
| Gold | The Toy Trove |
| Silver | The Brick Shack |
| Bronze | Toys "R" Us |
| Top Pick | Build a Friend |
| Top Pick | Freakshow Comics |
| Top Pick | L Rae and Maeve |
| Top Pick | M & L Sports Cards and Collectables |
| Top Pick | Mastermind Toys |
| Top Pick | Mostly Comics |