| Platinum | Dohboy's Diner |
| Gold | Beechwood Doughnuts |
| Silver | Country Fresh Donuts |
| Bronze | Beamsville Bakery Patisserie |
| Top Pick | Country Style |
| Top Pick | Edible Options |
| Top Pick | Fenwick Pie Co. |
| Top Pick | Homestead Donuts & Garden City Bakery |
| Top Pick | Tim Hortons |
| Top Pick | Zehrs Welland |