| Platinum | Farm Boy |
| Gold | Real Canadian Superstore |
| Silver | Tim Hortons 4th Ave |
| Bronze | Half Baked Bagel Co. |
| Top Pick | COBS Bread Bakery |
| Top Pick | Edible Options |
| Top Pick | Harvest Barn of St. Catharines |
| Top Pick | Mitchell’s Bakery & Market Place |
| Top Pick | The Bagel Oven |
| Top Pick | Tim Hortons - East Main ST Welland |