| Platinum | Mom Dukes Authentic Jamaican Cuisine |
| Gold | Memphis Fire BBQ |
| Silver | Slobsrus BBQ |
| Bronze | Merrittville Smokehouse |
| Top Pick | Backroad Barbecue Company |
| Top Pick | Billy Bones BBQ |
| Top Pick | Dane's Smokehouse |
| Top Pick | Montana's BBQ & Bar |
| Top Pick | Smoke & Moonshine BBQ |
| Top Pick | Storm's Fresh Meat & Deli |