| Platinum | Lemayzz Meats |
| Gold | Farm Boy |
| Silver | Goemans Lakeshore Meats & Deli |
| Bronze | Tender Cuts |
| Top Pick | Antipastos |
| Top Pick | Big Red Market |
| Top Pick | Richard's Fine Meats & Deli |
| Top Pick | Storm's Fresh Meat & Deli |
| Top Pick | The Meat Shoppe - Niagara |
| Top Pick | Theodore's Butcher Shop |