| Platinum | Carmine's Pizzeria Italiano |
| Gold | Christopher's Pizza |
| Gold | The Barrel Restaurant |
| Silver | Farm Boy |
| Bronze | Pizza House |
| Top Pick | Dominos Fonthill |
| Top Pick | Frank's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | RT Pizza |
| Top Pick | Storm's Fresh Meat & Deli |
| Top Pick | The Pizza Company |